The 10 Best Mystery Anime, Ranked by How Fairly They Play the Game

By the MyAnimeVerse team · Updated · 13 min read

Part of Best anime by genre

The Apothecary Diaries

A mystery works when the answer was in front of you the whole time. The best mystery anime hide their clues in plain sight: a line of dialogue in episode two, a background detail, a character who is a little too helpful. When the reveal lands, you want to go back and rewatch, not throw your remote. Bad mysteries do the opposite and pull a twist out of nowhere.

This guide is one of the genre lists that branch off our ranking of the best anime of all time. We ranked ten mystery series you can stream on MyAnimeVerse right now, weighing how well each one plays fair with the viewer, its AniList score, how often it shows up on critics' and fans' lists, and how quickly the first episode hooks you. We also skipped a few famous titles that already headline other lists on this site, and explain where to find them at the end.

What kind of mystery do you want?

"Mystery" covers a lot of ground in anime. Picking the right kind matters more than picking the highest score.

  • Classic whodunit. A body, a closed set of suspects, a detective who explains it at the end. Detective Conan, Kubikiri Cycle and Gosick.
  • Everyday puzzles. No murders, just small, odd questions solved with logic. Hyouka is the model, and The Apothecary Diaries does it inside a palace.
  • Crime puzzle box. A big tangle of characters whose stories click together late. ODDTAXI and Baccano!.
  • Supernatural mystery. The rules include ghosts or time loops, and part of the fun is learning them. Summer Time Rendering and Ghost Hunt.

If what you really want is a cat-and-mouse battle of wits, that's a slightly different genre. Our best psychological anime list and anime like Death Note cover those mind games in depth.

1. ODDTAXI

ODDTAXI cover art

#1ODDTAXI

TV · 2021 · 13 episodes · OLM · 85% on AniList · Sub & dub

Drama, Mystery, Psychological

Watch ODDTAXI

Hiroshi Odokawa is a 41-year-old walrus who drives a taxi in Tokyo at night. He is grumpy, antisocial and observant. His passengers include a broke comedy duo, a college student desperate to go viral, a nurse, an idol hopeful and a pair of thugs, and almost all of them have some connection to a high school girl who has gone missing. The police start asking Odokawa questions.

ODDTAXI is a 2021 original anime from OLM and P.I.C.S., written by Kazuya Konomoto and directed by Baku Kinoshita. Everyone is drawn as an animal, which makes it look like a kids' show. It isn't. It's a crime story about gambling debts, social media, loneliness and the yakuza, told almost entirely through conversations in the back of a cab.

That's why it tops this list. Nearly every throwaway line in the first half turns out to matter, and the final episode reorganizes everything you've seen in a way that's surprising and completely fair. The first episode is chatty and slow on purpose: two comedians argue, Odokawa grumbles, and you'll wonder where it's going. Give it three episodes. At 13 episodes, it's also one of the easiest mysteries here to finish in a weekend. Best for viewers who like dialogue-driven crime fiction and listening closely.

2. The Apothecary Diaries

The Apothecary Diaries cover art

#2The Apothecary Diaries

TV · 2023 · 24 episodes · OLM · 88% on AniList · Sub & dub

Drama, Mystery

Watch The Apothecary Diaries

Maomao is a sharp, unsentimental young woman trained as an apothecary in the pleasure district. She is kidnapped and sold into the emperor's inner palace as a lowly servant, where she plans to keep her head down and wait out her contract. Then she figures out why the emperor's infant children keep falling ill, leaves an anonymous warning, and is promptly found out by Jinshi, a beautiful and very persistent palace official who starts handing her every strange case in the court.

The Apothecary Diaries (Kusuriya no Hitorigoto), adapted by Toho Animation Studio and OLM from Natsu Hyuuga's novels, is the best current example of the "everyday puzzle" mystery. The cases are poisonings, forged letters, ghost rumors and odd illnesses, and Maomao solves them with chemistry, medicine and a working knowledge of how people lie. Each one is short, but they add up to a larger story about palace politics that rewards paying attention.

The first season runs 24 episodes, with a second 24-episode season in 2025 and a third airing now. Our Apothecary Diaries watch order lays out all three. The first episode is a strong start, with the baby-illness case solved by the end. Best for viewers who want a smart heroine and mysteries without gore, and for fans of historical drama; our best historical anime list is a good next stop.

3. Hyouka

Hyouka cover art

#3Hyouka

TV · 2012 · 22 episodes · Kyoto Animation · 79% on AniList · Sub & dub

Mystery, Romance, Slice of Life

Watch Hyouka

Houtarou Oreki lives by one rule: if he doesn't have to do something, he won't, and if he has to, he'll do it quickly. His sister pushes him into joining his high school's nearly dead Classic Literature Club, where he meets Eru Chitanda, a girl whose curiosity is so strong she can't let anything go. Soon Houtarou is spending his energy solving her questions: why a room was locked, why a club anthology has a strange title, what happened at the school 45 years ago.

Kyoto Animation's 2012 adaptation of Honobu Yonezawa's novels runs 22 episodes. Hyouka has no murders and no villains, and that's the point. The mysteries are small, and the satisfaction comes from watching Houtarou reason his way through them. The longer arcs, including a mock murder-mystery film the club has to finish and a festival with a string of thefts, are as tightly plotted as any detective story.

It is also one of the best-looking school anime ever made, with KyoAni's trademark detail and a slow-building friendship between Houtarou and Chitanda. Some viewers find the pace too gentle. The first episode, a locked-classroom puzzle, tells you right away whether its style works for you. If it does, our best Kyoto Animation anime guide has more from the same studio.

4. Summer Time Rendering

Summer Time Rendering cover art

#4Summer Time Rendering

TV · 2022 · 25 episodes · OLM · 83% on AniList · Sub & dub

Action, Drama, Mystery

Watch Summer Time Rendering

Shinpei Ajiro comes home to a small island off the coast of Wakayama for the funeral of his childhood friend Ushio, who drowned saving a little girl. But the marks on her neck don't match a drowning, and people on the island whisper about "shadows" that copy a person and replace them. Within days, Shinpei is killed, and wakes up on the ferry back to the island, at the start of the same day.

OLM's 2022 adaptation of Yasuki Tanaka's manga runs 25 episodes. Summer Time Rendering is a time-loop mystery, and Shinpei's limited number of loops gives it real stakes. Each reset, he learns a little more about who on the island has been replaced and what the shadows want. It's closer to a thriller than a slow puzzle, with action and horror in the back half.

It's our pick for viewers who loved the loops in Re:Zero or the setting of a closed rural community, and the first episode ends on a strong hook. If the time travel is what grabs you, our best sci-fi anime list has Steins;Gate and more.

5. Baccano!

Baccano! cover art

#5Baccano!

TV · 2007 · 13 episodes · Brain's Base · 81% on AniList · Sub & dub

Action, Mystery, Supernatural

Watch Baccano!

In the opening scene, a newspaper editor and his assistant argue about where a story should begin. That's the entire premise of Baccano!: three timelines, 1711, 1930 and 1931, cut together out of order, with a cast of alchemists, mobsters, thieves, a psychopath in a conductor's uniform and two cheerful petty criminals who are the best part of the show. Much of it takes place on a transcontinental train, the Flying Pussyfoot, where several gangs board at once and things go very wrong.

Brain's Base made it in 2007 from Ryohgo Narita's light novels, and it runs 13 TV episodes plus three extras. It has a jazz opening and a Prohibition-era style that makes it stand out from every other show here. It's violent, often very funny and confusing for the first few episodes, because the show wants you to piece the order together yourself.

The question isn't "who did it" so much as "how does all of this connect," and the answer is satisfying. Watch the first three episodes in one sitting. Best for viewers who like Tarantino-style ensembles and nonlinear stories.

6. Detective Conan

Detective Conan cover art

#6Detective Conan

TV · 1996 · TMS Entertainment · 82% on AniList · Sub & dub

Adventure, Comedy, Mystery

Watch Detective Conan

High school detective Shinichi Kudo follows two suspicious men in black, gets knocked out and is forced to swallow an experimental poison. Instead of killing him, it shrinks him into a child. Hiding his identity, he calls himself Conan Edogawa and moves in with his childhood friend Ran and her father, a bumbling private detective, whose cases Conan quietly solves while hunting the organization that poisoned him.

TMS Entertainment's adaptation of Gosho Aoyama's manga has been running since 1996 and is past 1,100 episodes, with a new film nearly every year. Detective Conan, also known as Case Closed in English, is the purest whodunit on this list. Most episodes are self-contained murder cases with a fair set of clues, a reveal and a deduction scene, and the long-running Black Organization plot ties it together.

Nobody needs to watch it all. Episode one, a roller-coaster murder and the shrinking, is a fine start, and many fans skip around to the key story episodes after that. Our Detective Conan watch order explains which episodes and films carry the main plot. Best for viewers who want a case a night for years.

7. Moriarty the Patriot

Moriarty the Patriot cover art

#7Moriarty the Patriot

TV · 2020 · 11 episodes · Production I.G · 80% on AniList · Sub & dub

Drama, Mystery, Psychological

Watch Moriarty the Patriot

Victorian England is rotten with class cruelty, and young William James Moriarty decides to fix it with crime. Working with his brothers, he arranges "accidents" for corrupt aristocrats who abuse the poor, with the goal of tearing the class system down. Then a scruffy consulting detective named Sherlock Holmes begins to notice the pattern.

Production I.G's 2020 adaptation of the manga by Ryosuke Takeuchi and Hikaru Miyoshi runs 24 episodes across two parts. Moriarty the Patriot flips the usual detective formula: you watch the crime planned and carried out, then watch the investigator try to catch up. The early episodes are standalone revenge stories, and the series gets much better when Sherlock arrives and it becomes a duel between two geniuses.

Fans of the original Holmes stories will enjoy spotting the references. Best for viewers who like heists, period drama and morally gray leads.

8. Gosick

Gosick cover art

#8Gosick

TV · 2011 · 24 episodes · bones · 77% on AniList · Sub & dub

Drama, Mystery, Romance

Watch Gosick

It's 1924, and Kazuya Kujo, a Japanese exchange student, is studying in the small, fictional European kingdom of Sauville. Classmates call him the "black reaper" because of his dark hair and eyes. In the top of the academy's huge library tower lives Victorique, a tiny, rude, brilliant girl who reads all day and solves murders by "reassembling the fragments of chaos," as long as Kazuya brings her the facts and her sweets.

Bones adapted Kazuki Sakuraba's novels in 2011, and the series runs 24 episodes. Gosick starts as a classic two-person detective story, with a murder on a ship and a fortune-teller's death, and slowly turns into a larger mystery about Victorique's mother and the kingdom's politics. The Sherlock-and-Watson pairing is the heart of it, and Victorique's gowns and the gothic setting give it a look nothing else here has.

Some of the early cases are thin and the resolutions can feel rushed. It gets stronger in the second half. Best for viewers who want an old-fashioned detective duo with a romance underneath.

9. Kubikiri Cycle

Kubikiri Cycle: The Blue Savant and the Nonsense User cover art

#9Kubikiri Cycle: The Blue Savant and the Nonsense User

OVA · 2016 · 8 episodes · Shaft · 76% on AniList · Sub

Drama, Mystery, Psychological

Watch Kubikiri Cycle: The Blue Savant and the Nonsense User

An exiled heiress invites a handful of geniuses, including a painter, a cook, a scholar and a fortune teller, to stay at her mansion on a tiny island in the Sea of Japan. One of the guests is Tomo Kunagisa, a blue-haired engineering savant who can't be left alone, and she brings along her narrator friend, a deadpan young man everyone calls Ii-chan. Then one of the guests is found with her head cut off, in a room nobody could have entered.

Shaft released this eight-episode OVA in 2016 and 2017, adapting the first of NisiOisiN's Zaregoto novels. Kubikiri Cycle is the most traditional locked-room mystery on this list, and the most talkative: NisiOisiN (who also wrote Monogatari) loves long, winding conversations, and much of the show is characters testing theories on each other.

The solution is clever and fair, and the double reveal in the final episodes is the reason it's ranked. It's also violent in places. Best for viewers who like Agatha Christie setups and don't mind a lot of dialogue. If Shaft's style is new to you, our Monogatari watch order covers the same writer's best-known series.

10. Ghost Hunt

Ghost Hunt cover art

#10Ghost Hunt

TV · 2006 · 25 episodes · J.C.STAFF · 73% on AniList · Sub & dub

Comedy, Horror, Mystery

Watch Ghost Hunt

High school student Mai Taniyama is telling ghost stories with friends when she runs into Kazuya Shibuya, a teenage paranormal investigator so arrogant that she nicknames him Naru, short for narcissist. After she accidentally breaks his equipment and injures his assistant, she ends up working for his agency, Shibuya Psychic Research, along with a monk, a shrine maiden, a Catholic priest and a spirit medium who rarely agree on anything.

J.C.Staff's 2006 series runs 25 episodes and adapts Fuyumi Ono's novels, the same author behind Shiki and The Twelve Kingdoms. Ghost Hunt is a case-of-the-week ghost mystery, with each haunting lasting two to four episodes. The team measures temperature drops and checks old records, and the cause is not always supernatural. Some cases turn out to be very human.

The animation is dated, but several cases are genuinely creepy. Best for viewers who want horror-lite mysteries; if you want the full fright, Ono's Shiki tops the slow-dread section of our best horror anime list.

Honorable mentions

Monster cover art

Monster

TV · 2004 · 74 episodes · MADHOUSE · 88% on AniList · Sub & dub

Drama, Horror, Mystery

Watch Monster

Monster is the most common answer to "what's the best mystery anime," and it deserves that. A surgeon saves a boy's life and years later has to hunt down the serial killer that boy became. It's left off the ranking only because it already headlines our all-time and Death Note lists, and at 74 episodes it's a big commitment. Watch it anyway.

ERASED cover art

ERASED

TV · 2016 · 12 episodes · A-1 Pictures · 81% on AniList · Sub & dub

Drama, Mystery, Psychological

Watch ERASED

ERASED sends a 29-year-old back to his childhood to stop a string of child kidnappings. Its first half is excellent; its ending divides fans, and the identity of the culprit is easy to guess.

Bungo Stray Dogs cover art

Bungo Stray Dogs

TV · 2016 · 12 episodes · bones · 77% on AniList · Sub & dub

Action, Comedy, Mystery

Watch Bungo Stray Dogs

Bungo Stray Dogs is a detective agency with superpowers, named after real Japanese authors. It's more action than puzzle, but its first season opens with cases. See the Bungo Stray Dogs watch order for all five seasons.

Two more worth knowing: The Promised Neverland season one is an escape-plan mystery about orphans who learn what their cozy home really is (skip the weaker second season), and Steins;Gate is a time-travel mystery hiding inside a sci-fi show (see anime like Steins;Gate). Higurashi: When They Cry, the bloodiest puzzle box around, is ranked in our horror list.

Best mystery anime at a glance

RankTitleYearEpisodesKind of mysteryScore
1ODDTAXI202113Crime puzzle box85
2The Apothecary Diaries202324Palace cases88
3Hyouka201222Everyday puzzles79
4Summer Time Rendering202225Time-loop thriller83
5Baccano!200713Nonlinear ensemble81
6Detective Conan19961,100+Case of the week82
7Moriarty the Patriot202024Inverted detective80
8Gosick201124Detective duo77
9Kubikiri Cycle20168Locked room76
10Ghost Hunt200625Paranormal cases73

Scores are AniList averages out of 100. Moriarty's episode count covers both parts.

How to pick your first mystery anime

If you've never watched one, start with The Apothecary Diaries: each case is short, the heroine is easy to like and nothing is graphic. If you want one complete story you can finish fast, ODDTAXI or Baccano!. If you want something to watch on and off for months, Detective Conan. And if you're the kind of viewer who pauses to check a background detail, Kubikiri Cycle and Hyouka were made for you.

A few habits help with any of them. Watch the first two or three episodes before judging, since mysteries spend early episodes planting clues. Avoid comment sections until you finish, because spoilers spread fast. And if a show seems to wander, it usually isn't wandering.

Mystery anime FAQ

What is the best detective anime?

For a detective in the classic sense, Detective Conan is the longest-running and best known. For a smaller, sharper detective story, Gosick and The Apothecary Diaries are both easier to finish. Monster, technically about a doctor, is the most acclaimed.

Are there mystery anime without murder?

Yes. Hyouka has none at all, and most of The Apothecary Diaries' cases are about poison, politics and palace gossip rather than killings.

Is Death Note a mystery anime?

Partly. It's a detective story told from the killer's side, so the suspense is about whether L catches Light, not who did it. Moriarty the Patriot uses the same structure. Our anime like Death Note guide has more in that vein.

Where can I find more mystery anime?

Browse our mystery anime category, filter the whole catalogue by year and status, or check the weekly schedule for mysteries airing this season. You can also sample first episodes on Discover, our swipe-through feed of episode-one previews, before you commit.

Final thoughts

ODDTAXI is our top pick because it's the rare mystery that's even better the second time, when you can see every clue it planted. The Apothecary Diaries is the best one airing now, and Hyouka is proof that a mystery doesn't need a body to be gripping. If you finish these and want darker territory, our horror and psychological lists pick up where this one ends, and the full best anime of all time ranking links to every other genre guide we've written.

More from the blog